Reviewing AI-Drafted Strategy Memos Like an Executive Editor
A smooth draft hides its weak spots. Three passes find them in the order that matters.
Read an AI-drafted strategy memo in three passes. First match each figure, date and name to your notes and fill the gaps. Then test the argument: is the decision at the top, and are the cost and the owner named? Last, cut the padding. A person approves before it goes out.
You can spot an unedited AI draft by how smoothly it moves past the hard questions. The sentences read well and the headings are tidy, and by page two you still don't know who owns the work, what it costs, or why the plan beats what you tried last year.
Pass 1: check the facts and the gaps
Start with what the AI agent could not have known. If it was told to mark what is missing, search the draft for "Gap in the notes" and fill each one in your own words. BNEDai's published method for strategy memos has the AI agent write that line where a part has nothing, and list every gap after the memo.
Then match every figure, date and name to a sentence in your notes or a primary record. A figure with no match came from somewhere else. Compare the list of gaps with what you remember leaving out. A skipped topic with no gap line means the AI agent wrote around it.
Confidence isn't evidence here. Check the output against a fact, not its tone. A polished draft can still be wrong.
Pass 2: test the argument
Read once from top to bottom without fixing the grammar. Ask three blunt questions.
- Is the decision you want, and the date it's needed by, at the top?
- Does every major claim rest on your own data, customer evidence or plain operational logic?
- Where did the draft smooth over a trade-off or assume the best case?
Replace a vague line such as "this will improve cross-functional alignment" with the exact change and its owner, or cut it. Check that the favored option is the one you chose, in your words. If you named no favorite in the notes, the memo should say so and not pick one.
Pass 3: cut what you can
Delete opening sentences that only restate the heading above them. Replace passive phrasing with an active verb and a name. Turn a dense paragraph into short lines, or into a table when options are being compared. If the draft still reads as if someone else wrote it, How Do You Keep an AI Agent From Sounding Like AI? covers the check that a word list misses.
The editor still owns the decision
The decision, and the yes before anything leaves. The AI Readiness Index asks whether a named person says yes before an AI-assisted action reaches the outside world, and whether a person verifies AI-produced claims and numbers before they go to a client or the public.
The three passes are BNEDai's suggested order, a checklist and not a published method.
A team makes this routine by moving pass one into the instructions
Put pass one into the AI agent's instructions, so the gaps and the "nothing added" rule arrive with every draft and the review has less to catch. Using AI to Draft Strategy Memos Without Losing Your Judgment covers drafting from your own notes, and Setting Quality Standards When Multiple Team Members Run AI Workflows covers keeping standards the same across people. How Do I Stop an AI Agent From Telling Me What I Want to Hear? is the page on testing the work before you trust it.
Take the AI Readiness Index to see where your team's rules for reviewing AI work are written down.
Frequently asked questions
What should I check first in an AI-drafted memo?
The facts and the gaps. Match each figure, date and name to your notes, and fill every gap line in your own words.
How do I know the AI agent didn't add something?
A figure, date or name with no matching sentence in your notes came from somewhere else. A skipped topic with no gap line means the AI agent wrote around it.
Who approves the memo?
A named person, before it goes out. The AI agent drafts and a person decides.
Reviewed on November 20, 2026.