Skip to article

A Lead Scoring Rubric an AI Agent Fills In With Evidence

Build an AI agent in Gumloop that fills your lead rubric one row per criterion, with the line it found on the lead's own pages, or Unknown.

By Jacqueline V. TwillieNovember 10, 20266 min readGuide
Quick answer

Write a rubric of a few criteria, each with what a 0, 1 and 2 look like, then build an AI agent in Gumloop and tell it to read only a lead's own pages. It fills one row per criterion with the line it found, copied as printed, or Unknown. Unknown is listed apart, and you add the marks.

Your lead sheet lists each lead's company, contact and where you met, and the fit column isn't filled in yet.

A rubric you write once puts the same questions to every lead. The AI agent answers them from the lead's own published pages, one row for each criterion, with the line it found copied as printed. A criterion with no line is Unknown, and it's counted apart from the marks.

What does a lead's score look like when every point has a line?

A row holds the criterion, the line from the lead's page copied exactly as printed, the address of that page, and a mark of 0, 1 or 2 taken from the sentences you wrote. A 0 is a line that shows a miss, such as a page naming customers unlike yours. A criterion with no line behind it gets Unknown, and Unknown is never a 0.

Under the rows, the AI agent writes the marks as a plain addition and stops before the equals sign. You'll add them. The block bars weights and benchmarks.

How do you build the lead scorer in Gumloop?

  1. 01

    Write what a 0, a 1 and a 2 look like for each criterion.

    Pick a few things a lead's own pages can show. Write one sentence per mark. A 2 is a line that fits you well. A 1 fits in part, and a 0 is a line that shows a miss. Leave off any criterion no public page could show, like a lead's budget. Then write the sum that earns a follow-up, and how many Unknown you'll accept, before any lead is scored.

  2. 02

    Put the rubric into the block and connect nothing.

    Open Gumloop, start a new AI agent and describe the job in a sentence: score a lead against my rubric using only its own pages. On the tab named Agent, paste the block below with your rubric written in and press Save. Paste each lead's name and page addresses into the chat, and the rows come back there to copy into the sheet.

  3. 03

    Keep Web Fetch, switch off Web Search and spot an empty page.

    In the Abilities section, switch off Web Search. Web Fetch reads the content of a specific URL. The table gives no word on pages that fill in after the first view, so the block has the AI agent print the first line it read from each page. Open one lead's page in your own browser and compare. If your screen shows a section no row mentions, the page may have filled in after the first view, and that lead's Unknown rows may come from a page the AI agent couldn't see. Checked on 2026-11-09 against the abilities table on Gumloop's AI agent builder page.

  4. 04

    Turn off Edit Own Instructions and set Reflections to Review Queue before the first lead.

    Find Edit Own Instructions under the instructions box, turn it off and press Save again. You'll tighten a wrong mark's sentence in the box yourself. Reflections can still propose instruction changes on a schedule, and new AI agents on the Pro plan and above start with it on, set to Auto-Apply Suggestions. On the Performance page, use the settings icon on the Reflections header and set Apply Suggestions to Review Queue, so a suggestion waits for you. Checked on 2026-11-11 against the builder and self-improving instructions sections of Gumloop's AI agent builder page and Gumloop's Reflections page.

  5. 05

    Score a lead you won and one you lost, then type in the sums.

    Paste each name with its page addresses and ask for the rows. You'll add the marks yourself and set each sum against your line for a good lead. If a result looks wrong, open the rows where a mark disagrees with your sentences and tighten that sentence in the box. Then type each sum into the fit column, with the Unknown names beside it.

I am an ambassador for Gumloop. Code SMBIZ takes 20% off your first month.

What do you paste into the instructions for the lead scorer?

Copy and fill in
You score business leads for [MY BUSINESS]. You contact no one and send nothing.
My rubric has these criteria. Each says what a 0, a 1 and a 2 look like. A 0 needs a line that shows a miss.
[CRITERION ONE, WITH ITS 0, 1 AND 2 SENTENCES]
[CRITERION TWO, WITH ITS 0, 1 AND 2 SENTENCES]
[CRITERION THREE, WITH ITS 0, 1 AND 2 SENTENCES]
For each lead I give you its name and the addresses of its own pages. Read only those pages. Use no search, no memory, no weights and no benchmarks.
For each criterion, write one row: the criterion, the line you found copied exactly as printed, the page address, and a mark of 0, 1 or 2 from my sentences. If no line speaks to the criterion, the mark is "Unknown". Unknown is never a 0.
Before the rows, give the first line you read on each page, as printed. If a page gave you no text, or only a menu or footer, write "Page empty" for it and mark every criterion that depended on it "Unknown".
After the rows, write the marks as a plain addition and stop before the equals sign. I add them myself. On the next line, name the criteria marked "Unknown".

When does a blank row mean the page, and when the lead?

Start with a lead that has several Unknown rows and open its pages in your own browser. If you find a line the row left out, send the AI agent that address with the criterion's name and ask it to try again. If it still returns Unknown for a line you can see, that row is yours to read.

Then redo one lead's sum from its rows. A mark that doesn't follow your 0, 1 or 2 sentences means the sentence is too loose, so tighten it in the box.

When a sum clears your line, build the AI agent that drafts the next note with How Do I Build an AI Agent That Follows Up With My Leads?. Keep the rubric as written until your leads change. Before a first meeting with a lead that clears your line, read How Do You Research Someone Before a First Meeting With an AI Agent?.

Frequently asked questions

What if I'd rather score from 1 to 10?

Use it when you can write what each of the ten levels looks like for every criterion, and put those sentences in the block in place of the 0, 1 and 2 lines. If you describe only the ends, the middle marks come from no sentence of yours, and you can't check them against your rubric.

What does an Unknown row cost a lead?

Nothing in the marks. The row is left out of the addition and its criterion is named on its own line. Read that page yourself before you rely on the sum.

More on Data for Non-Technical Managers