How Do I Build an AI Agent That Follows Up With My Leads?
Build an AI agent in Gumloop that reads your inbox and lead sheet, scores who is real, and drafts your next note to each lead for your approval.
Build an AI agent that reads your inbox and a lead sheet each morning, scores each person from 0 to 3 with the sentence behind every point, and drafts your next note to each one. Its instructions say draft only. With Ask for writes/deletes set, a Gmail tool that writes waits at an approval card for your yes.
Five names is enough to start. They're the people who wrote in, asked about working with you, or said they'd think about it, and they haven't heard from you since.
You're the owner and the sales team, so follow-up waits behind the work you're already doing. A message sits unanswered and a row in your lead sheet goes stale.
An AI agent can read that inbox and that sheet every morning, score who's real, and draft the next note for each person. You still decide who gets a reply and what it says. For my October 1 live session I described the build this way: "This AI agent reads your inbox and your lead sheet, scores who's real, and drafts the next note for each one. Nothing sends without your yes."
What does the lead follow-up AI agent hand you each morning?
A short list, highest score first. Each person on it has a score from 0 to 3, the sentence from their message or your sheet that earned each point, the day of the last message, and a draft of your next note.
Anyone who scores 0 or 1 gets one line with the reason. When the AI agent can't find the evidence for a point, it writes "not found" beside that point and leaves the guess to you.
How do you build the lead follow-up AI agent in Gumloop?
- 01
Put your five names in a sheet.
Open a Google Sheet and give each person a row, with columns for name, company, where you met, the date of your last message, and what they asked you for. Add your five. Leave out anything private that has no business in a sales sheet.
- 02
Open Gumloop and start the AI agent.
In Gumloop, create a new AI agent. Guided setup asks what it should take care of. Answer in one sentence: "Draft my next note to each lead who's waiting on me."
- 03
Connect Gmail and Google Sheets, then change both approvals.
Open the Connectors section, select + Add and pick both. Gumloop's default approval is Always allow, so click the approval icon beside each connector and choose Ask for writes/deletes. Reads run freely, and a tool that writes stops at an approval card. Leave "Don't ask again for this tool" unticked. How Do You Control What an AI Agent Can Do in Gmail? goes further. Checked on 2026-11-11 against Human in the loop, Gumloop's AI agent builder page and Gumloop's connector help page.
- 04
Paste the instructions, then turn Edit Own Instructions off.
Open the tab named Agent, paste the block below and fill every bracket. Edit Own Instructions sits right under the instructions box. It's on by default and keeps no version history. Turn it off for this job. Keep a copy of the filled version, then press Save.
- 05
Start with the five names, by hand.
Open a new task and type: "Score my five names and draft the next note for each." Read every score beside your own sense of that person.
- 06
Approve one draft and rewrite it.
Pick the person you're surest about, approve the draft if an approval card asks, then look for it in Gmail and rewrite it in your voice. Note how much you changed. The rules in What Rules Should You Give an AI Agent for Drafting Replies? cover the sentences you keep changing.
- 07
Add the morning trigger last.
Open the Triggers tab, select Add trigger, choose Scheduled Trigger and describe the schedule in plain language, such as "every weekday at 7:00 AM". Write the prompt it receives: "Work through this morning's follow-ups as described in your instructions." Run the same prompt by hand for a few mornings first. Checked on 2026-11-09 against Gumloop's triggers page.
I am an ambassador for Gumloop. Code SMBIZ takes 20% off your first month.
What do you paste into the instructions for the lead follow-up AI agent?
You are my lead follow-up assistant at [BUSINESS NAME]. You work for me, the owner, who is also the only salesperson. My goal is to reply to the people who are ready to buy before they go quiet. Each morning, read only these three things: the unanswered messages in my inbox from the last [NUMBER] days, the rows in [LEAD SHEET NAME], and my last [NUMBER] sent notes so you can match how I write. Score each person from 0 to 3. Give one point for each of these you can find in their own words or in the sheet: 1. They asked for a quote, a date or a next step. 2. They can decide: [WHAT A BUYER LOOKS LIKE IN MY BUSINESS]. 3. Something from the last [NUMBER] days is waiting on me. List everyone who scores 2 or 3, highest first. For each person give the score, the sentence behind each point, the day of their last message, and a draft of my next note in no more than [NUMBER] sentences. People who score 0 or 1 get one line with the reason. If you cannot find evidence for a point, write "not found" beside it. Never guess a budget, a date or a name. You draft only. You never send, reply, forward or edit the sheet. Every draft waits for my yes. Be [STANDING BEHAVIOR ONE]. Tell me plainly when you are guessing.
What should you check before you trust the morning list?
Open the message behind each point on the first few lists. A point with no sentence behind it is a guess, so tighten the "never guess" line until those stop.
Look for the lead you know went cold, the one who said maybe and never wrote again. If that person scores 3, your second question is too loose, so narrow the words you put in its blank.
Watch the third point. A thread you answered yesterday shouldn't come back today, and if it does, the AI agent isn't reading your sent notes. For a lead's scores filled in from the lead's own pages, read A Lead Scoring Rubric an AI Agent Fills In With Evidence.
Frequently asked questions
What if my lead sheet is mostly empty?
The AI agent still reads your inbox and writes "not found" beside every point it can't find in the sheet. The empty columns tell you what to fill in first.
When can I let the morning trigger run on its own?
After a few mornings by hand where the top of the list matches your own read of who's real, let it run on its own.
Can it send the notes without me?
It isn't set up to. The instructions say draft only, and the page sets Ask for writes/deletes, so a Gmail tool that writes waits at an approval card for your yes. Open Tool Management to see which group your draft tool sits in.