How Should an AI Agent Pair Gives and Gets in a Counter-Offer?
Build an AI agent in Gumloop that pairs each term a buyer asked to change with what it costs you and the one return you want, and flags any term with none.
You fill in the costs, limits and returns, and an AI agent in Gumloop pairs every term a buyer asked to change with what giving it costs you and the one thing you want back. A term with no return stays flagged and out of the draft. Its instructions bar figures, a proposed walk-away line and sending.
"What do I get for that?" is the question to put to yourself on each line of a buyer's list of changes.
Every term the buyer asked to change gets two lines before anything is drafted: what giving it costs you, and the one thing you want in return. Both come from a trade sheet you write once, in your words.
What does a give and get pair hold?
Give is your cost of moving the term, copied from your sheet. Get is the one thing you want back, also copied from your sheet.
A term with no line on your sheet, or a line with no return, comes back marked "No return named." It stays flagged in every plan and stays out of the draft reply, which offers only the pairs that have a return.
When an ask goes past the limit you wrote, the pair says "Past your limit." When it touches your walk-away line, the plan says that and leaves the call to you. For the person-side version of a counter, see How Do I Script a Salary Counter-Offer With an AI Agent?
What do you paste into the instructions for the counter-offer plan?
You help me, [YOUR NAME], [YOUR ROLE] at [COMPANY], plan the trades in a counter-offer. In each task I'll paste the terms a buyer asked to change. My walk-away line, in my words: [WALK-AWAY LINE]. Print it at the top of every plan, exactly as written. Never propose, soften or move a walk-away line. My trade sheet, one line in this form for each term I can move: [TERM] | the most I can move it: [LIMIT] | what giving it costs me: [COST IN MY WORDS] | the one thing I want back: [RETURN] For each term the buyer asked to change, write a Give line and a Get line, copied from my sheet. Make up no figure, benchmark or claim about what buyers accept, and do no arithmetic. If an ask goes past a limit, write "Past your limit" beside it. If an ask touches my walk-away line, write "Touches your walk-away line" beside it and leave the call to me. If a term has no line on my sheet, or its line has no return, write "No return named" and repeat that flag in every plan until I add a return. Then write a short draft reply in my voice that offers only the pairs that have a return. A flagged term never goes into it. I'll read it before anything goes out. Send nothing.
How do you build the counter-offer plan in Gumloop?
- 01
Write each term you can move, with its limit, its cost and one return.
A term is a line in the agreement, such as how long it runs or when payment is due. Beside each, write the most you can move it, what moving it costs you in your own words, and the one thing you'd want back. The block copies your words and does no arithmetic.
- 02
Write your walk-away line before a buyer's list is open.
Put it on its own line, in words you'd say to a colleague. If you haven't settled it, How Do I Build a Negotiation Prep AI Agent With L.A.T.T.E.? is where yours gets set.
- 03
Give a new AI agent the block and press Save.
In Gumloop, start a new AI agent whose one job is the counter-offer plan. On the tab named Agent, paste the block into the instructions box, put your sheet and your walk-away line on its lines and press Save. Checked on 2026-11-09 against Gumloop's AI agent builder page.
- 04
Switch off Web Search and Web Fetch and leave Connectors empty.
Both are rows under Abilities. Checked on 2026-11-09 against the abilities table of Gumloop's AI agent builder page.
- 05
Turn off Edit Own Instructions under the box that holds your walk-away line.
The toggle sits right below the instructions box. Checked on 2026-11-09 against the self-improving instructions section of Gumloop's AI agent builder page.
- 06
Check the pairs against a deal you've already closed.
Paste the list of changes from a deal you've already closed. Each Get line should match your sheet word for word. Then delete one return in the box, save and run it again. That term should read "No return named" and be missing from the draft reply.
I am an ambassador for Gumloop. Code SISSUMMIT2026 takes 20% off your first month.
What does a flagged pair tell you before you reply?
Each flagged pair is a concession with no return. Count them yourself, since the block asks for no count. For each one, either write a return on your sheet or decide to give the term away on purpose, and if you give it away, write that sentence into your reply yourself.
Set each Get line beside your sheet. A Get line that differs from the sheet means the plan added a return, and the block's copy rule is the first line to check.
Look at the top of the plan for your walk-away line, word for word. If a sentence in the draft offers a term that touches it, the call to hold or move is yours. Update the sheet when a deal closes. To compare a call's outcome with the numbers you set beforehand, see How Do I Build an AI Agent That Debriefs Me After a Renewal Call?
Frequently asked questions
What if the buyer asks for a term that isn't on my sheet?
It comes back marked "No return named" and stays out of the draft. Add a line for it to the sheet in the box, with your limit, cost and return, then save and run the list again.
Can it send the reply to the buyer?
With Connectors empty there's no connected app for it to send with, and the block has it send nothing. You'll read the draft and send it yourself.
What if I want to give a term away on purpose?
That term stays flagged on every plan, and the draft leaves it out. Add the sentence to your reply yourself once you've decided.